Skip to content
Search
Close this search box.
  • Join
  • Login
  • Join
  • Login
  • Membership
    • Renew
    • Join
    • Practice (A+)
    • Member rewards
  • Online store
  • Explore Architecture
    • Find an architect
    • Working with an architect
    • Education & Standards
    • Living Architecture
    • Reading Architecture
    • Pathways to architecture
    • Archi Ed
    • Hearing Architecture podcast
    • Notable buildings
    • Venice Biennale
    • Open House Hobart
  • What’s On
    • Country Culture Community
    • FUTURE SHOCK: Designing City Resilience
    • Open House Hobart
    • Venice Biennale
    • All Events
  • Advocacy & News
    • Community Forum
    • Policy & Advocacy
    • Submission Library
    • Media Releases
    • News
    • NSW Design & Building Practitioners Act and Regulations
    • Sustainability and climate action
    • First Nations
    • Diversity & Equity
  • Awards, Prizes & Tours
    • 2023 National Architecture Awards Winners Gallery
    • Awards Program
    • Prizes
    • 2024 Dulux Study Tour
    • National and Chapter Architecture Awards Program
    • 2023 Gold Medal Tour
    • 2023 Smeg Tour
  • Preparing to register
  • CPD, Education & Resources
    • Overview
    • Wellbeing for architects
    • Purchase On Demand CPD
    • Face-to-Face CPD
    • Refuel CPD Courses
    • Practice Resources
    • National Mentoring Program
    • Showcase
    • Become a CPD Provider
  • Chapters
    • ACT
    • International
    • NSW
    • NT
    • QLD
    • SA
    • TAS
    • VIC
    • WA
  • EmAGN
    • About
    • Emerging Architect Prize
    • EmAGN Project Award
    • EmAGN Representatives
    • EmAGN Online Resources
    • Living Village Design Competition
  • SONA
    • Join
    • Beyond Uni
    • Advocacy
    • About
    • de-PICT
    • Member Benefits
    • Upscale
    • Super Studio 2023
    • Representatives
    • Representative Application
    • Study
    • Contact SONA
  • About Us
    • 2023 Annual General Elections – NOMINATIONS OPEN NOW
    • About the Institute
    • Board of Directors
    • National Council & Committees
    • Chapter Councils & Committees
    • Our Staff
    • Annual Reports
    • Work with Us
    • Contact Us
  • Partnerships
    • Corporate Partners
    • Supporting Partners
    • Partnership & Advertising Opportunities

Between words and images

Architecture's lived experience

  • 21 April 2021
Peter Salhani
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Bagsværd Church | Jørn Utzon | Copenhagen | Seier + Seier

In the digital age there’s every reason to think that the photograph is taking over as the medium for how we read and understand architecture. 

 

More accessible than the written word – and particularly architectural writing that’s heavily theoretical and excludes many from the conversation – an image captures and records a physical moment. But in the seeing of it, imagination can edit that moment, implying alterations and atmospheres that allow us to recognise something beyond the object of the image. So, it is both literal and highly subjective.

Few explorations of this idea are as compelling as John Berger’s 1972 opus, Ways of Seeing, a book that changed the modern world. In his introduction Berger wrote:

‘Seeing comes before words. The child looks and recognises before it can speak… It is seeing that establishes our place in the world; we can explain that world with words, but words can never undo the fact that we are surrounded by it. The relation between what we see and what we know is never settled.’

The same can be said of architecture. Whatever else has motivated or inspired it, architecture’s spatial purpose is – arguably – best understood by experiencing it ourselves, both as an object in space and as the space within an object. That’s not to invalidate the more considered explanations of a building’s conceptual origins, but it doesn’t make the scholarly review the only path to enlightenment either. Our lived experience may be less erudite and informed but is no less valid. As a writer/interpreter in this space, I’m equally drawn to the visceral response as I am to a scholarly metaphor.

To give culture – particularly the art world – a shakedown, Berger drew together threads of Marxism and art theory to supplant scholarly writing with the primacy of the image. He did it in a visual way, coupling post-Renaissance paintings of nudes with contemporary posters and magazine centrefolds, to prove how similarly they objectified women for the gratification of men.

Audience is crucial to any communication, because we perceive the world subjectively through the lens of our own experience and imagination. This makes the internet such a great enabler in the consumption of architecture – as well as everything else – with archi-porn from around the globe emailed, blogged, Instagrammed and tweeted 24/7. Thousands of projects with crisp headlines and saturated images. Filtering for meaning is overwhelming, so most of us toggle somewhere between surrender and retreat.

Berger reflects on cinematic editing as a crucial driver of narrative, using ‘long vistas and close-ups one after the other’ to craft a story that is not explained but implied. Much of architecture in the media uses this same tactic – to tease narratives out of photographs – but are all narratives equal?

No. In making the medium mainstream, the internet has democratised authorship. Notwithstanding the power of global titans to wield their influence by working the algorithms that harvest and distribute information online, today – in terms of tools and training – all you need to be a publisher is a smart phone and some digital images. No cadetship in journalistic ethics, balance, fact checking and proofreading, just photographs and a few lines of text. Digital publishers have capped our attention spans at 800 words and rarely like to test this limit. And let’s not even start on train-wreck TV shows like The Block or House Rules – a race to the bottom of the renovation-to-riches barrel – offering neither insight nor useful critique, just banal blabbering about taste and real estate value.

At the other extreme is the architects’ own austere website and self-published monograph. Both favour the image over the written word – by reducing barely legible typefaces to mere graphic imprints on a page – knowing that however much or little is written about a project, the images are incontrovertible and seemingly un-editorialised. Architects have long understood this; it’s the basis of their symbiotic relationship with photographers. Indeed, a number of eminent Australian photographers in the field have also studied architecture, creating an interesting chicken-and-egg scenario.

But understanding architecture for me is also experiential. I am not religious, but when I visited Jørn Utzon’s Bagsværd Church on the outskirts of Copenhagen, I was moved beyond words. I’d read almost nothing about this unassuming building, which from the street looks a bit like a warehouse. Perhaps my reaction was to the Utzon story. Perhaps it was because his church – all light, warmth and wit – was the incandescent opposite of the cold oppressive Catholic churches of my childhood, in which I felt diminutive and diminished.

Having spent a large chunk of my life mediating architecture and the thinking behind it to many different audiences – mainly through words but also through the curation of images – I’ve come to believe that words and images are equally important. Before Berger, the Gestalt psychologists of the early 20th century posited that in human perception the ‘whole is greater than the sum of its parts’. So, between words and images, combined in a thoughtful way, there may be no dichotomy at all. The image sets imaginations soaring, while the words ground it in context, so that each benefit from the other.

Peter Salhani is a freelance architectural journalist published online and in print, and a content creator for design-based clients. He is a former editor of architectureau and Monument magazine, and co-founder of sparkkle.space, an independent platform interviewing creatives from architecture, design and social action. From 2013-2020 he served on the NSW Architects Registration Board, representing consumers and the public interest.

Published online:
21 Apr 2021

Source:
Architect Victoria
Lost for Words
May / Jun
2021

More from Architect Victoria

Yakimono: Russell & George

28 Nov 2023
A layered sensory experience, Russell & George’s Yakimono draws on the experience of a typical late-night Izakaya to plate-up a restaurant that is reminiscent of Japanese concepts, without ...
Read more

Valparaiso + architect Cazu Zegers

16 Oct 2023
Composed of forty-four hills and a flat area oriented to the bay, the busy and sometimes worn-down working port of Valparaiso, Chile, is a natural ...
Read more

Darebin Intercultural Centre: Sibling Architecture

4 Sep 2023
By prioritising community as the driving force behind their design, Sibling Architecture’s Darebin Intercultural Centre stands as a welcoming new community facility, aspiring to nurture meaningful ...
Read more

Guangzhou + architect Atelier Deshaus

27 Aug 2023
Guangzhou, my hometown and where my grandparents live, is the capital and largest city of Guangdong province in southern China. It is a bustling city with ...
Read more

Garden House: BKK Architects

14 Jul 2023
Garden House is an enduring home which successfully creates a spatial model that is specific to the couple occupying it (and their two cats). It ...
Read more

Deco House: Mihaly Slocombe

22 May 2023
Preserving the historic fabric of the original Art Deco building, Mihaly Slocombe have created a home filled with light. Providing room for a family to ...
Read more

Nightingale Anstey: Breathe

17 Apr 2023
Homes are complex places, and we expect a lot from them. It’s easy to forget the range of functions that they are often required to ...
Read more

Creating an underwater garden

13 Feb 2023
City skylines increasingly feature roofs and walls that are covered in foliage to trap stormwater and moderate internal climates. This approach to greening is now ...
Read more

Autumn House: Studio Bright

2 Feb 2023
The gardens of Autumn House are not only instrumental in gifting the clients the tranquil home they desired, but also act as an offering of ...
Read more

Skin deep

19 Jan 2023
I was making a left turn onto Lygon Street, towards East Brunswick, when my passenger, one of three founders of our Stockholm-based architecture practice, began ...
Read more

Arthur: Oscar Sainsbury Architects

5 Dec 2022
A central deck is not only Oscar Sainsbury Architects' solution to the site’s flooding overlay, but a core part of their resulting design. Oscar’s aspirations ...
Read more

Apartment design guidelines as architecture

31 Oct 2022
In 2016, the Victorian government implemented the Better Apartment Design Standards (BADS) into the Victoria Planning Provisions (VPP) and all its planning schemes.
Read more

La Mama Theatre Rebuild: Meg White with Cottee Parker Architects

24 Oct 2022
Tasked with capturing the identity and idiosyncrasies of a meaningful cultural space, the La Mama Theatre Rebuild by Meg White with Cottee Parker Architects illustrates ...
Read more

Sharing cities with nature, by design 

27 Sep 2022
As an urban ecologist, I specialise in the science and practice of nature conservation in cities. This strikes most people as unusual. Surely, nature conservation ...
Read more

Balfe Park Lane: Kerstin Thompson Architects

14 Jul 2022
Considered across the scales of the neighbourhood, building and apartment, Kerstin Thompson Architects’ recently completed Balfe Park Lane is a demonstration of medium-density housing that ...
Read more

Re-valuing

8 Jun 2022
Through process and approaches that engage with multiple notions of heritage including problematic ones of environmental and cultural destruction, architecture can participate in the widening ...
Read more

Maggie Edmond: Edmond & Corrigan

7 Jun 2022
Edmond & Corrigan has employed an incomparable number of young architects who have gone on to have prolific careers with their own practices or as ...
Read more

A crucible for new housing typologies

12 May 2022
Faded photos of public housing projects from the early 1980s line the corridor walls of the Department of Families, Fairness and Housing, marking the time ...
Read more

Napier Street for Milieu: Freadman White

10 May 2022
Freadman White’s simultaneous development of Napier Street and Whitlam Place harnessed unique efficiencies and resulted in a highly efficient model for project delivery.
Read more

Amelia Borg, Kushagra Jhurani and Peter Elliott: How to get a job

3 Apr 2022
Early career professionals are often guided by a practice’s development guidelines. Many help by pairing graduates with an experienced graduate, registered architect, or even an ...
Read more
Back to Reading Architecture
Instagram Youtube Linkedin-in Facebook-f Tiktok Pinterest
Chapters
  • ACT
  • International
  • NSW
  • NT
  • Queensland
  • SA
  • Tasmania
  • Victoria
  • WA
ARCHITECTURE.COM.AU
  • What’s On
  • Policy & Advocacy
  • Membership
  • Awards
  • CPD
  • About Us
  • SONA
The Institute
  • Join
  • Online Store
  • Member Portal
  • Partnership & Advertising Opportunities
  • Contact Us
  • Media Releases
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

The Australian Institute of Architects acknowledges First Nations peoples as the Traditional Custodians of the lands, waters, and skies of the continent now called Australia.

We express our gratitude to their Elders and Knowledge Holders whose wisdom, actions and knowledge have kept culture alive.

We recognise First Nations peoples as the first architects and builders. We appreciate their continuing work on Country from pre-invasion times to contemporary First Nations architects, and respect their rights to continue to care for Country.

Read our Statement of Support for the Uluru Statement from the Heart and Constitutional Recognition and the Voice to Parliament.

© Australian Institute of Architects

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT

This form is now closed.